9 Comments

very captivated by this essay. appreciate your nuance and honesty! family is complicated no matter the set up

Expand full comment
author

Thank you!

Expand full comment

Wonderful. The photo too. I am glad for your family’s hard-won happiness.

Expand full comment
author

Whatever happened to the Beatles thing? Did you get my email? Or just very busy? Which is fine!

Expand full comment

Sending you an email.

Expand full comment
May 12·edited May 12Liked by Susan Bordo

Happy Mother's Day, Susan!

I am 58 and just identified my bio parents via Ancestry ca

Unfortunately, my bio mom passed in 2017, so I will never know her. My bio father didn't know about me.

I was raised by people the same age as my bio grandparents.

And you know what?

I'm glad! They are my family.

I lucked out and I know it.

My Mom loved us more than anything and I like that she imparted a longer-inforned worldview to me and my brother.

Plus, if my bio father's Facebook is any indication, he is an eternal puer who grew pot and played guitar his whole life. Not a bad life for him but I actually shudder to imagine growing up with him as a father figure.

Same love? Different love?

Real family?

I know who my real family is.

💐

Expand full comment

My mom was adopted as a baby, and so was her brother. She will be 60 this year and never expressed any interest in finding out any information about her birth parents. My uncle died in 2022 from a brain tumor. He did want to know more about his birth parents in the end, but the last few months of his life he was so ill, he was very angry with his father and I don’t think they got anywhere in the conversations. I was asked about my grandparents because my mom’s mother had beautiful red hair, so people generally knew she wasn’t genetically related to us. When I was struggling with infertility, I of course was asked if I would adopt, but after 3.5 years of trying we did eventually conceive when I was 31, and our daughter is now 4. I don’t really know that we had a plan of what we would do if I couldn’t eventually have a baby, but we didn’t really ever consider adoption because it was such a long expensive process that we frankly didn’t feel like we could afford.

Thank you for sharing your story- Cassie is so lucky to have so many people who love her!

Expand full comment

I adopted my daughter 46 years ago. She is from Colombia; my stepson, African American, adopted 53 years ago, is from Kansas. One of the things that is interesting and somewhat disturbing for me is that both children have recently thanked me for adopting them; one has used the word "saving" them. It highlights for me how I do not totally understand the depth of their feelings about being adopted, about being given away or not wanted, about being rescued. For me, it is not so complicated: they are my children.

I have written about my adoption of Quin: Awaiting Quintana: A Journal of Adoption November 19, 1976-August 23, 1977

Nan Bauer Maglin

Frontiers: A Journal of Women Studies

Vol. 3, No. 2, Mothers and Daughters (Summer, 1978), pp. 49-53 (5 pages)

Published By: University of Nebraska Press

Expand full comment
deletedFeb 17
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
author

I wish I could give this comment fifteen hearts instead of just one. Thank you so much. What you say about the enmeshment of biology post-birth is so true—and I’ve never seen anyone say it before. And so beautifully. Heart, heart, heart.

Expand full comment